Gary returns from Germany to support his son Santi at the tournament and asks to take over as Santi's caddy, influencing him by recalling past tournaments where his guidance helped Santi win. Initially supportive and praising Santi's skills, Gary soon reveals his true colors by becoming angry and frustrated when Santi makes mistakes, affecting Santi's composure during the competition.

Gary's return and request to be Santi's caddy displaces Pryce, causing tension. Mitts visits Pryce, who is drinking alone, indicating Pryce's distress over losing his role. Gary's controlling and critical behavior on the course contrasts with Pryce's previous supportive presence, straining Pryce and Santi's bond.

The title reflects the repetition of past patterns in Gary's behavior. Although he initially appears changed and supportive, Gary quickly reverts to being controlling and emotionally volatile, repeating the same mistakes that previously hurt Santi. This cyclical dynamic is central to the episode's emotional tension.

Elena, Santi's mother and Gary's ex-wife, along with Mitts, Pryce, and Zero, are wary and distrustful of Gary's involvement. Elena is particularly convinced that Gary will eventually hurt Santi again, reflecting their protective stance and skepticism about Gary's intentions.

The episode is set against the backdrop of the ReadySafe Invitational final, where Santi competes with Gary as his caddy. The competition highlights the emotional and psychological challenges Santi faces due to his father's presence. The episode also features a notable head-to-head moment with PGA pro golfer Colin Morikawa, emphasizing the high stakes of the tournament.